• 
  Mark Meer

  Narrator / VHS God (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Josh Lenner

  Ninja Sensei (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Kevin Martin

  Videostore Guy (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Charles Ghal

  Big Boss (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Tim Rutherford

  VHS Warrior (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Jeremy Kwan

  Punk Ninja (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Damian McDonald

  Punk Ninja (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Darryl Merpaw

  Punk Ninja (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")

• 
  Jesse Nash

  Punk Ninja (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Curt Engel

  Punk Ninja (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Nolan Smits

  Punk Ninja (segment "M is for Magnetic Tape")
• 
  Carolyn Purdy-Gordon

  Bonnie Phillips (segment "M is for Mormon Missionaries")
• 
  Glen Maynard

  (segment "M is for Mutant")
• 
  Michael Draper

  (segment "M is for Marriage")
• 
  Danielle Barker

  Victim (segment "M is for Manure")

• 
  Natalie Victoria

  (segment "M is for Marriage")
• 
  Adrian Gaeta

  Kyle (segment "M is for Mermaids")
• 
  Michelle Ferguson

  The Sacrifice (segment "M is for Messiah")
• 
  Jensen Bucher

  The Wife (segment "M is for Martyr")
• 
  Lawrence R. Greenberg

  The Cook (segment "M is for Martyr")
• 
  Gabriela Marcinková

  (segment "M is for Malnutrition")
• 
  Emi Kamito

  Victim 1 (segment "M is for Matador")
• 
  Mace Coronel

  (segment "M is for Mom")
• 
  Olena Venidiktova

  Girl (segment "M is for Matador")
• 
  Brett Glassberg

  Subject 2 (segment "M is for Mind Meld")
• 
  Mathias Retamal

  Matador (segment "M is for Matador")
• 
  Lulu McClatchy

  (segment "M is for Muff")
• 
  Nicholas Humphries

  Cult Members (segment "M is for Messiah")
• 
  Brooke J. Ferrell

  (segment "M is for Mom")
• 
  Lucinda Cowden

  (segment "M is for Mutant")
• 
  Judit Bárdos

  (segment "M is for Malnutrition")
• 
  Mark Popejoy

  Man 1 (segment "M is for Make Believe")
• 
  Ilker Arslan

  (segment "M is for Mobile")
• 
  Kevin Byrd

  Marauder Extras (segment " M is for Marauder")
• 
  Juan Bravo Jr.

  The Mariachi (segment "M is for Mariachi")
• 
  Josh Christensen

  The Awkward Man (segment "M is for Martyr")
• 
  David Blanka

  Darío (segment "M is for Miracle")
• 
  John Cianciolo

  Father (segment "M is for Manure")
• 
  Wesley Braxton

  Marauder Leader (segment " M is for Marauder")
• 
  Ken Campbell

  Lord Cock (segment "M is for Mariachi")
• 
  John Beck

  Townspeople (segment "M is for Martyr")
• 
  Beat Billson

  Bret (segment "M is for Merry Christmas"))
• 
  Ali Arslan

  (segment "M is for Mobile")
• 
  Anastasia Baranova

  Best Friend (segment "M is for Mother")
• 
  Don Bridges

  (segment "M is for Muff")