• 
  Robert Taylor

  Joel Shore
• 
  Stewart Granger

  Mark Shore
• 
  James Whitmore

  Fetcher
• 
  Robert Taylor

  Joel Shore
• 
  Keenan Wynn

  Silva
• 
  Robert Burton

  Asa Worthen
• 
  Betta St. John

  Native Girl
• 
  Lewis Stone

  Captain Holt

• 
  Stanley Andrews

  Matthew Shore's Father
• 
  Jonathan Cott

  Carter
• 
  John Doucette

  George
• 
  Ann Blyth

  Priscilla 'Pris' Holt
• 
  Walter Coy

  Noah Shore
• 
  Clancy Cooper

  Smith
• 
  Leo Gordon

  Peter How

• 
  Michael Pate (I)

  Varde, Second Mate
• 
  Kurt Kasznar

  Quint
• 
  James Bell

  Aaron Burnham
• 
  Mitchell Lewis

  Cook
• 
  John Lupton

  Dick Morrell, Third Mate
• 
  Peter Whitney

  James Finch, First Mate