• 
  John Adams

  Man on the street
• 
  Kristy J. Anderson

  Crime Scene Investigator
• 
  Dennis MaGee Fallon

  2nd SLPD Police Officer
• 
  Patrick O'Sullivan

  Reuben
• 
  Jamesen Re

  Detective Giovani Boniparti
• 
  Mark V. Jones

  1st SLPD Officer
• 
  Anthony Manion

  Bobby
• 
  Sharon Savene

  Jennifer Anderson

• 
  Alexandria Wailes

  Alison Mantillini
• 
  Hillary Baack

  Spiritual Advisor
• 
  Gerry Reyes

  Uncle Chris
• 
  Bethany Love Orr

  Interpreter
• 
  Modela Kurzet

  Jeff's mother
• 
  Gayle Gaston

  Jennifer's Birth Mother
• 
  Dea Divi

  3rd Female SLPD Officer

• 
  Frank Lala

  Family Friend #1
• 
  Kathy Holmes

  Family Friend #2
• 
  Matthew Blackwood

  LA County Detective
• 
  Mirian Franklin

  Wrong Mother
• 
  Camillo Faieta

  Jeff Contato
• 
  Casey Tinsley

  The Samaritan / The Neighbor
• 
  Katie McGloin

  Barista #1
• 
  Talia Dagan

  Secretary
• 
  Trina Watkins

  SLPD Dispatcher
• 
  Laura B. Ripplinger

  1st Female SLPD Officer
• 
  William T. Lester

  Family Friend #4
• 
  Harold Weston

  Barista #2
• 
  Nancy Ferraz

  Family Friend #3
• 
  Yohance Serrant

  LA County Liaison
• 
  Beth Bryson

  Naomi
• 
  Phillip Watkins

  Detective Simon Willis
• 
  Sarah Bogati

  Social Worker
• 
  Shareef Aquil

  Coroner #1
• 
  Emiliano Cipriano

  Evidence Analyst
• 
  Bridgett A. Jones

  Bridget / Housekeeper
• 
  Ricardo Mercado

  Coroner #2
• 
  Shannon Clark

  Alison's Co-Worker #2
• 
  Theresa B. Sharp

  House Manager
• 
  Frank Micheal Davis

  SLPD Detective
• 
  Rachelle Eaglin

  Alison's Co-Worker