• 
  Tommy O'Haver

  regizor

• 
  Tommy O'Haver

  scenarist
• 
  Irene Turner

  scenarist

• 
  Elliot Page

  Sylvia Likens
• 
  Catherine Keener

  Gertrude Baniszewski
• 
  Hayley McFarland

  Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens
• 
  Ari Graynor

  Paula Baniszewski
• 
  Evan Peters

  Ricky Hobbs

• 
  Paul Palo

  Newspaper Reporter
• 
  Scout Taylor-Compton

  Stephanie Baniszewski
• 
  Nick Searcy

  Lester Likens
• 
  Amy Ferguson

  Sally Kent
• 
  James Franco

  Andy
• 
  Hannah Leigh

  Shirley Baniszewski
• 
  Scott Eastwood

  Eric

• 
  Jeremy Sumpter

  Coy Hubbard
• 
  Romy Rosemont

  Betty Likens
• 
  Michael Welch

  Teddy Lewis
• 
  Kuma

  Baniszewski Dog
• 
  Patricia Place

  Mrs. Doyle
• 
  Edward James Gage

  aprod
• 
  Brian Geraghty

  Bradley
• 
  Michael O'Keefe

  Reverend Bill Collier
• 
  Michelle Benes

  Hope Orbach
• 
  Carlie Westerman

  Marie Baniszewski
• 
  Bradley Whitford

  Prosecutor
• 
  Tristan Jarred

  Johnny Baniszewski
• 
  Calvin Keet

  Mr. Doyle