• 
  Abby Elliott

  Jess (rumored)
• 
  Michael Goulis

  Casey (rumored)
• 
  Breckin Meyer

  Casey
• 
  Bryant Carroll

  Randy
• 
  Andrew Gorell

  Burt
• 
  Allen O'Reilly

  Abe Berkman
• 
  Emily Kinney

  Jess
• 
  Lisa Dapprich

  Pyschologist

• 
  Davis Aguila

  Antonio
• 
  Giselle Eisenberg

  Jules
• 
  Katherine DeBoer

  Connie Richman
• 
  Jonathan Chiarle

  Shooter
• 
  Cindy Fernandez-Nixon

  Nurse Espinoza
• 
  Lindsey Mitchell

  Rude Mommy
• 
  Mitch Randjelovic

  Young Casey

• 
  Debra Herzog

  Missy
• 
  Melinda Rodriguez

  Happy Burger Cashier
• 
  Aubree Stone

  Emily
• 
  Charlisa Anderson

  Cheryl
• 
  Brady Sherman

  Ryder
• 
  Andrea Zenovia

  New Girl
• 
  Carter Anderson

  Spencer
• 
  Chris Lipinski

  Jess' Dad
• 
  Paul Worley

  Casey's Neighbor
• 
  McKenna Stoffer

  Student
• 
  David Vegh

  Detective Dunn
• 
  Devito Parker Jr.

  Student
• 
  Rick Montgomery Jr.

  TV Missionary
• 
  Meg Rasmussen

  Young Dorothy
• 
  Sydney Brown Birch

  Student
• 
  Chris Bohan

  Steven Richman
• 
  Andrew Gordon

  Doctor
• 
  Daniel Repas

  Jeff Timlin