• 
  Melissa Chadwick

  Helena O'Donnell Walker
• 
  Laurel Kornfeld

  Karen
• 
  Frank Williams

  Robert Walker
• 
  Kimberly Bada

  Rochelle (rumored)
• 
  Jayson Soto

  Ryan Pierce (rumored)
• 
  Rajab Croswell

  Detective McDowell
• 
  Erik Searle

  Judas Gains
• 
  Wesley Green

  James Whitaker (rumored)

• 
  Cole Geissler

  Judas, Age 15 (rumored)
• 
  Jared Vasquez

  Daryl Burks (rumored)
• 
  Christopher Piatt

  Matthew Walker
• 
  Jose Roman

  Officer Ruiz (rumored)
• 
  Jessica Chadwick

  Jill (rumored)
• 
  TerriAnn Gladden

  Meredith Walker (rumored)
• 
  Megan Flynn

  Annie Reagan

• 
  Troy Latham

  Randall 'Randy' Wallace
• 
  Susannah Foos

  Karlee
• 
  Kristin N. Flynn

  Jessica Reagan
• 
  Juan Lords

  Travis
• 
  Kelly M. Flynn

  Young Sophia (as Kelly M. Flynn)
• 
  Michael Stinson

  Desmond
• 
  Ellen Cohn

  Angela McGowan
• 
  Michael Fallon

  Sam O'Donnell
• 
  David Izaguirre Jr.

  Chief Chamberlain
• 
  Victoria Stevens

  Paige
• 
  Samuel Oquendo

  Chase
• 
  Wayne Shearer

  Dark Priest
• 
  Ron Morrison

  Father Reagan
• 
  Mathaus J Gilles

  Nick Fox
• 
  Darren Johnson

  Det. Michael McDowell
• 
  Zay Rodriguez

  Manny
• 
  Ron Morrison

  Father Reagan
• 
  Mariel McIntosh

  Sherrie
• 
  Leia Emersyn

  Lawyer
• 
  Julie Chapin

  Mrs. Kennedy