• 
  Angel Connell

  Hotel Concierge / Conspirator
• 
  Alex Cash

  Cipriano Ferrandini
• 
  Brina

  Railroad Station Extra
• 
  Giovanni Alabiso

  Otis Hillard
• 
  Donald Crane

  Norman Judd
• 
  Paula Dellatte

  Railroad Station Extra
• 
  John Horrigan

  Host / Narrator
• 
  Jack Burk Goldman

  Businessman

• 
  Tomas Condon

  John Wilkes Booth
• 
  Shalaye Camillo

  Hotel Waitress
• 
  David Cook

  Businessman
• 
  Brian Dongelewic

  Policeman
• 
  Josh Brogadir

  Railroad Worker
• 
  Alex Bezanson

  Hotel Patron / Conspirator
• 
  Ryan Buckel-Gillis

  Policeman

• 
  Greg Shea

  Himself - Narrator
• 
  Daniel Stashower

  Himself - Interviewee
• 
  Jack Shipley

  Ward Hill Lamon
• 
  Gerry Marrocco

  Samuel Felton
• 
  Paul Held

  Governor Andrew Gregg Curtain
• 
  Mark F. Logue

  James Luckett
• 
  Doug Reed

  Harry Davies
• 
  Brendan Lynch

  Samuel Felton's Assistant
• 
  Jesse Seward

  Allan Pinkerton
• 
  Sharon Wood

  Mary Todd Lincoln
• 
  Patience McStravick

  Kate Warne
• 
  Stephen Wood

  Abraham Lincoln
• 
  Robert Marsella

  Railroad Conductor
• 
  Robert Oliva

  Railroad Worker
• 
  Daniel Stashower

  Self - Interviewee