• 
  Erville Alderson

  Mr. Adams
• 
  Alan Baxter

  Jesse James
• 
  Virginia Brissac

  Mrs. Hathaway
• 
  Walter Catlett

  Mr. Pettibone
• 
  Howard Da Silva

  Greg Bilson (as Howard da Silva)
• 
  Faye Emerson

  Martha Adams
• 
  Victor Jory

  William Merrick
• 
  Arthur Kennedy

  Jim Younger

• 
  Sam McDaniel

  Wash
• 
  Dennis Morgan

  Cole Younger
• 
  Wayne Morris

  Bob Younger
• 
  Russell Simpson

  Hank Younger
• 
  Hugh Sothern

  Fred Robinson
• 
  Dorothy Vaughan

  Mrs. Dalton
• 
  Jane Wyman

  Mary Hathaway