• 
  Hannah Barefoot

  Julie Nelson
• 
  Marlyn Mason

  Mildred Colvin
• 
  Douglas Rowe

  Pastor Ben Hastings
• 
  Abby Wathen

  Amanda Millard
• 
  Greg James

  Sheriff Joe Palin
• 
  John T. Woods

  Mark
• 
  Lindsae Klein

  Amanda's Mother
• 
  Michael Meyer

  Billy Colvin

• 
  Sandra Doolittle

  Amanda's Attorney
• 
  Sonya Davis

  Brittany
• 
  Max Gutfreund

  Brad
• 
  Liam O'Sruitheain

  Doctor Hanson
• 
  Ashley Layton

  Court Clerk
• 
  Nona Bingham

  Organist
• 
  Chuck Greenwood

  Amanda's Mom's Boyfriend

• 
  Olivia Jane Catmull

  Waitress
• 
  Paul J. Lipscomb

  Judge