• 
  Johnny Alonso

  Big Joe
• 
  Johnny Crawford

  William S. Hart
• 
  Darby Hinton

  Cole Younger
• 
  Gheorghe Muresan

  Little Joe
• 
  Matt Servitto

  Frank James
• 
  Ken Arnold

  Bill Tilghman
• 
  Kathy Searle

  Zoe Tilghman
• 
  Robert Neal Marshall

  William N. Selig

• 
  Brian St. August

  Wolfgang Gulman
• 
  Lawrence Whitener

  Old Joe
• 
  Earl Klemm

  Deputy Bear
• 
  Marc Goodman

  Bat Masterson
• 
  Marge Bowers

  Edith Hathaway
• 
  Robert Carradine

  Frank James
• 
  Lana Wood

  Ms. Darling

• 
  Leanna Chamish

  Mabel
• 
  Richard Cutting

  Murphy
• 
  Raw Leiba

  Woody
• 
  Donald Imm

  Darren Thomas
• 
  Christine Nelson

  Melody Selig
• 
  Eliza Kelley

  Alice
• 
  Zach Steffey

  Chuck Tilghman
• 
  Jesse Milliner

  Chicken Man
• 
  Don Collier

  Red
• 
  George Stover

  Mr. Martin
• 
  Jason Brown

  Arkansas Tom
• 
  John Buttram

  Boyd
• 
  Patrick W. Boyer Jr.

  Little Joe
• 
  Jim Holland

  Prison Guard 1
• 
  Amy S. Young

  Barmaid
• 
  Michael Hagan

  Warden
• 
  Gale Nemec

  Wardrobe Mistress
• 
  Russell G. Voelker

  Prisoner
• 
  Griffin McCahill

  Tench Tilghman