• 
  Ted Marcoux

   Narrator
• 
  Alex Cherman

   Bowery Boy (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Cameron McIntosh

   Bowery Boy (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Eduardo Pagán

   Himself - Historian (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Gregory Cioffi

   Bowery Boy / ... (3 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Kyle Patrick

  2 episodes, 2016
• 
  Joseph K. Bevilacqua

  Randall McCoy
• 
  David Gazzo

  James DeRemer

• 
  Anthony Misiano

  Edwin Tewksbury
• 
  Joe Penczak

  Devil Anse Hatfield
• 
  Steve Bono

  Thomas Graham
• 
  Cory Boughton

  Frank Walcott
• 
  Steve Cavanaugh

  Nate Champion
• 
  Bill Coyne

  Frank Canton
• 
  Bryan Manley Davis

  William Jackson Palmer

• 
  Douglas Everett Davis

  Frank Reid
• 
  Brian Colin Foley

  Yankee Sullivan
• 
  Leah Gabriel

  Mary Ann Tewksbury
• 
  Anthony O'Connell

  Nick Ray
• 
  Wes Hager

  Jim Turner
• 
  Jonathan Gregg

  John Morrissey
• 
  Holly Stanford

  Ella Watson
• 
  Zach McNally

  John Aton McMurtrie
• 
  Christopher Spurrier

  Ellison Hatfield
• 
  Nate Washburn

  Ray Morley
• 
  Dillon Mathews

  Cattle Baron
• 
  Benjamin W. Jones

  John Graham
• 
  David Serero

  Mr. Matchum
• 
  James Zeiss

  Boxing Referee
• 
  Nathaniel Peart

  Devil Anse Hatfield
• 
  Giuseppe Pollicino

  John Tewksbury