• 
  Toby Meuli

  Mark Faxon
• 
  Matthew Brumlow

  Burton Rose
• 
  Clinton Pickens

  Ned the Copy Clerk
• 
  Ka Beesler

  Karl Klug
• 
  Elizabeth A. Davis

  Heather
• 
  Cora Vander Broek

  Jill Temple
• 
  Stan Denman

  Tammy's Dad
• 
  DeAnna Toten Beard

  Andrea

• 
  Jency Allison Weeks

  Evvy Rose
• 
  Omari Williams

  Pet Store Clerk
• 
  Sam Henderson

  Detective Samuels
• 
  Lisa Denman

  Tammy's Mom
• 
  Ryan Artzberger

  Earl Ambrose
• 
  Jaime Lee

  Shay
• 
  Colyer Dermody

  Troy

• 
  Hope Caviness

  Tammy Slonicker
• 
  Corey Carbonara

  Detective Samuels' Partner
• 
  Bill Beard

  City Hall Security Guard
• 
  Jeanne Dittmann

  Support Group Member
• 
  Mary Elliott

  Support Group Member
• 
  Dacey Dougherty

  Jennifer's sister
• 
  Jordan Richard

  Heather's husband
• 
  Robert Hagins

  Henry, Heather's son
• 
  Ava Hansen

  Katie, Heather's daughter