• 
  Mike Still

   Mike (6 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Grace Parra

   Erin (4 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Jennifer Bartels

   Jen (6 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Jimmy O. Yang

   Donny (3 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Jackie Zebrowski

  (4 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Hunter Clowdus

  Seaton
• 
  Ray Wise

  Gene
• 
  Pam Murphy

  Nancy (2017)

• 
  Liza Kerns

  Party Guest
• 
  Stella Edwards

  Jen (5 years old)
• 
  Rich Fulcher

  Tee (The Bodega Clerk)
• 
  Will Hines

  Kevin the Waiter
• 
  Lil Rel Howery

  Paulie Tapes
• 
  John Milhiser

  Bohemian Pastor
• 
  Ego Nwodim

  Carmen

• 
  Veronica Osorio

  Heather
• 
  William Romeo

  Hunter
• 
  Ashley Ann Hale

  Jackie Tapes
• 
  Drew Tarver

  Adam Sinclair
• 
  Carl Tart

  Nerdy Shelf Stocker
• 
  Greg Vrotsos

  Jay