• 
  Brian Alevis

   Eddie (6 episodes)
• 
  Greg Contaldi

   Charlie (6 episodes)
• 
  Alain Gr-Polanco

   Jude (6 episodes)
• 
  Robert Zaia

   Salvatore Bracco (4 episodes)
• 
  Joe Basile

   Goombah / ... (4 episodes, 2016-2017)
• 
  Patrick Swearingen

  Ben Chase
• 
  Bob Saypol

   Tommy Servitto / ...
• 
  Megan Tomei

  Judy

• 
  Randy Rossilli

  Sal, Jr.
• 
  Lisa Tirone King

  Angelica
• 
  Abigail Hawk

  Melissa
• 
  Conor Hovis

  Jim Brown
• 
  Robert Funaro

  Agent Benacquista
• 
  Charles Goonan

  Grease Director
• 
  John Lacovara

  Tony Gualtieri

• 
  P.J. Leonard

  Charlie's Dad
• 
  Gil V. Borrero

  Mafioso
• 
  Pat Swearingen

  Ben Chase