• 
  Karen Black

  Mrs. Buttleman
• 
  Dan Castellaneta

  Human Canonball
• 
  Ryan Alosio

  Luke Buttleman
• 
  Greg Benson

  Todd
• 
  Leon Russom

  Reverend Buttleman
• 
  Rusty Schwimmer

  Ronette
• 
  Duane Whitaker

  Mitch
• 
  Dawn Balkin

  Libby Gunther

• 
  Dylan Kenin

  Becky's Husband
• 
  Jeff Doucette

  Wally
• 
  Anita Barone

  Wendy Blitzer

• 
  Adam Blau

  music department