• 
  Ryan Bergara

  Self - Host
• 
  Ryan Bergara

   Himself (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Ryan Bergara

  30 episodes, 2016-2018
• 
  Shane Madej

  29 episodes, 2016-2018
• 
  Brent Bennett

  Self - Host
• 
  Kathryn Olmsted

  Self - Professor of History, UC Davis
• 
  Belfazaar Ashantison

  Self - Voodoo Practitioner
• 
  Tina Mattingly

  Self - Executive Director of Waverly Hills

• 
  Peggy Williams

  Self - Willow Creek Museum Docent
• 
  Laura Roland

  Self - Manager, Gatekeeper Paranormal
• 
  Everette Hoard

  Self - Commodore
• 
  Jennifer Fernandez

  Self - Bartender at May Baily's
• 
  Giorgio Tsoukalos

  Self - Ancient Aliens Expert
• 
  Hannah Williams

  Self - Buzzfeed Producer
• 
  Lydia Woodall

  Self - Manager, Village Pizza

• 
  Sharon Coyle

  Self - Rolling Hills Owner
• 
  Kristin Lee

  Self - Owner, Bellaire House
• 
  Loey Lane

  Self - Beauty Vlogger
• 
  Pepe Hernandez

  Self - BuzzFeed Mexico
• 
  Gary Thomas

  Self - Pastor & Exorcist