• 
  Ryan Bergara

  Self - Host
• 
  Ryan Bergara

   Himself (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Shane Madej

   Himself (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Ryan Bergara

  Himself
• 
  Brent Bennett

  8 episodes, 2016
• 
  Daysha Edewi

  Self - Superfan
• 
  Stuart Goldstein

  Robber
• 
  Zodiac Killer

  Self

• 
  Jake Bergara

  Artemus Ogletree
• 
  Brenden Dahle

  Second guard
• 
  Josh Davis

  Morning-shift guard
• 
  Kyle Drew

  Interrogator
• 
  Ian Martin

  Richard E. Abath
• 
  Kevin McShane

  Morning-shift guard
• 
  Branden Smith

  Rolf Rørtvedt

• 
  Patrick Ward

  Robber
• 
  Chloe Zak

  Isdal Woman