• 
  Kelly Marcus

  Yeshua / Jesus
• 
  Terry Jernigan

  Christian School Principal
• 
  Jason Richards

  Conservative Mennonite Pastor
• 
  Rebecca Ellen Kurtz

  Rebecca
• 
  Rachel Sonvico

  Conservative Mennonite 2
• 
  Chris Korkalo

  Rebecca's Father
• 
  Molly Jean Wick

  Young Rebecca
• 
  Lauren Henry

  Conservative Mennonite Girl 3

• 
  Hunter Fisher

  Home Church Pastor
• 
  Ella Zimmerly

  Cousin Ella
• 
  Aida Denisse Prybylski

  Seancer
• 
  Delilah Prybylski

  Student Delilah
• 
  John Ferguson

  NPS Volunteer
• 
  Skyler Jones

  Perfect Teen Christian
• 
  Lisa Cox

  Chicago Principal

• 
  Alex Seals

  Home Church Pastor's Wife
• 
  Rosanne Hinshaw

  Rebecca's Mother
• 
  Gavin Phillibert

  Backsliding Teen Christian
• 
  McKenna Lafontaine

  Student 1
• 
  Ryeniah McHenry

  Student 5
• 
  Naomi Kocher

  Conservative Mennonite 1
• 
  Lynn Kenny

  Conservative Mennonite Sunday School Teacher
• 
  Michael Bailey

  Abraham
• 
  Samantha Carrillo

  Student 4
• 
  Jason Zimmerly

  Episcopal Priest
• 
  Lisa Ford

  Doctor
• 
  Cecilia Espinoza

  Student 2
• 
  Boston Vigeant

  Student 3
• 
  Josiah Austin

  NPS Atheist Ex-Boyfriend
• 
  Carol Ann Webster

  Christian School Teacher