• 
  Katherine Haber

  Rachel
• 
  Alyssa Haber

  Onlooker
• 
  Elizabeth Saint

  Clara Tyler
• 
  Hays Wellford

  Silas
• 
  David Armanino

  Josh
• 
  Brian Colin Foley

  Dean
• 
  Adrian Arthur

  Rodney
• 
  Madison Baumgardner

  Young Amy

• 
  Dan Manson

  Dan Manson
• 
  Mark Collmer

  Wendall
• 
  Sasha Gardee

  Penny
• 
  Buddy Blankenship

  Coach Manson
• 
  Mark Ryan Anderson

  Shawn
• 
  Victoria Baccini

  Amy
• 
  Alex Tordi

  Dustin

• 
  Emily Elizabeth Czerniakowski

  Chloe
• 
  Grace Kubus

  Young Chloe
• 
  Robert Casey Williams

  Young Shawn
• 
  Lea Davis

  Sophie (as Lea Falcione)
• 
  Tyler Hentz

  Young Dustin
• 
  Michael Bulluck

  Young Rodney