• 
  Busy Philipps

  Shannon
• 
  Gillian Jacobs

  Martha
• 
  Allie Bencar

  Musician in Bar
• 
  Andrea Richardson

  Sherry
• 
  Anjali Atul Mehta

  Pharmacist
• 
  Bob Ingersoll

  Curmudgeon
• 
  Brendan Potter

  Sgt. Richard Lennox
• 
  Brent Reichert

  Police Officer #2

• 
  Brian McCann

  Baseball Guy #2
• 
  Catherine Anderson

  Sherry's Friend #1
• 
  Charlie Martini

  Daryl
• 
  Christian Prentice

  Sean
• 
  Christina Cacic

  Jill
• 
  Christine McBurney

  Bee Girl #1
• 
  Christopher Lavdas

  Baseball Guy #1

• 
  Christopher Mele

  Store Manager
• 
  Dan Anders

  Police Officer #1
• 
  Dan Sanek

  Alex
• 
  Daniel Temelkoff

  Tom
• 
  David Biscella

  Bartender
• 
  Deanna Holmes

  Grog Shop Production Assistant
• 
  Deanna Sherman

  Waitress in Diner
• 
  Denny Blaze

  Bank Manager
• 
  Derek Koger

  Paul
• 
  Dominique Paramore

  Dominique
• 
  Douglas Slygh

  Restaurant Patron
• 
  Ebani Edwards

  Sheree's Sister
• 
  Eric Frank

  Guy in Grog Shop
• 
  Erik Cribley

  Lewis
• 
  Evie Neal

  Apartment Resident
• 
  George Roth

  Saul
• 
  Hakeem Sharif

  Tarik
• 
  Imani Sherfield

  Randall
• 
  Jackson Biesecker

  Mike
• 
  James McGilbray

  Dr. Monroe
• 
  Jason Botsford

  Andy
• 
  Jason Meyers

  Bar Guitarist
• 
  Jason Patrick

  Bartender in Grog Shop
• 
  Jason Sleisenger

  Young Saul
• 
  Jeffrey Grover

  Donnie
• 
  Jennifer Dillon

  Sister #2
• 
  Jessy Leigh

  Naveen
• 
  Jimmie Lee Williams

  Antwon
• 
  Joe Gallipoli

  Bank Customer
• 
  Joe Zamora

  Jason
• 
  Karey Dornetto

  Streaker
• 
  Kathi Crawford Buck

  Maureen
• 
  Kristin Wilkinson

  Bee Girl #2
• 
  Leon Bibb

  Thomas
• 
  Linda Ryan

  Evelyn
• 
  Patrick Antone

  Guy in Library
• 
  Tonya Broach

  Drunk Butch Girl
• 
  Michael Goulis

  Tim
• 
  Robbie Barnes

  Girl in Library
• 
  Robert Branch

  Cook