• 
  Celeste Holm

  Sister Scholastica
• 
  Loretta Young

  Sister Margaret
• 
  John Bleifer

  Rosey
• 
  Robert Foulk

  Policeman, New York City
• 
  Hugh Marlowe

  Robert Masen
• 
  Thomas Gomez (I)

  Luigi Rossi
• 
  Edwin Max

  Whitey
• 
  Basil Ruysdael

  The Bishop

• 
  Gary Pagett

  Johnnie Matthews
• 
  Wally Brown

  Howard Sheldon
• 
  Louis Jean Heydt

  Al Newman
• 
  Henri Letondal

  Father Barraud
• 
  Walter Baldwin

  Claude Jarman, the realtor
• 
  Regis Toomey

  Monsignor Talbot
• 
  Mike Mazurki

  Sam

• 
  Elsa Lanchester

  Amelia Potts