• 
  Lou Diamond Phillips

  Monsignor Renzulli
• 
  Jo-Ann Robinson

  Louisa Reilly
• 
  J.W. Smith

  Apartment Manager
• 
  Mikki Val

  Betty
• 
  Gregory Alan Williams

  Judge Watford
• 
  David Joseph Martinez

  Mario Batista
• 
  Elton LeBlanc

  Doctor
• 
  John Newberg

  Kent Dunbar

• 
  Lauren Elise

  Nicki
• 
  Ladson Deyne

  Father John
• 
  Yohance Myles

  Willis Silk Thompkins
• 
  Edy Ganem

  Alejandra Batista
• 
  Aaron Tveit

  Tommy Reilly
• 
  Shaquita Smith

  Nurse
• 
  Aaron Mitchell

  Juror

• 
  Jeanne Caldarera

  Sister Jean
• 
  Lauren Helling

  Jane Kennedy
• 
  Anthony Barbier

  Courthouse cop
• 
  Theta Catalon

  Jury Foreman (as Theta Catalon)
• 
  Camryn Jones

  Samantha
• 
  Cynthia LeBlanc

  Courtroom Spectator
• 
  Leslie Anne Whitman

  Nurse