• 
  Claire Trevor

  Miss Mary McCloud
• 
  John Wayne

  Bob Seton
• 
  Ed Brady

  Juror
• 
  Raymond Walburn

  Judge Buckner
• 
  Edward Hearn

  Jury foreman
• 
  Jack Low

  Juror #2
• 
  Dick Rich

  Dental patient #1
• 
  Ray Bennett

  Guerrilla

• 
  Trigger

  Fletcher 'Fletch' McCloud
• 
  Marjorie Main

  Mrs. Cantrell, aka Mrs. Adams
• 
  Porter Hall

  Angus McCloud
• 
  Edmund Cobb

  Juror #3
• 
  Trevor Bardette

  Mr. Hale (shot by Fletch)
• 
  Edward Earle

  Town leader
• 
  J. Farrell MacDonald

  Dave (gunrunner)

• 
  Frank Hagney

  Tough Yankee #2
• 
  Lloyd Ingraham

  Orăşean
• 
  Walter Long

  Orăşean
• 
  Betty Farrington

  Townswoman
• 
  George 'Gabby' Hayes

  Andrew 'Doc' Grunch
• 
  Harry Cording

  Angry townsman in bank
• 
  Richard Alexander

  Phil (guerrilla guarding Seton)
• 
  Ernie Adams

  Orăşean
• 
  Walter Pidgeon

  William 'Will' Cantrell
• 
  Roy Rogers

  Fletcher 'Fletch' McCloud
• 
  Harry Strang

  Man about to withdraw his money from bank
• 
  Stanley Blystone

  Tough
• 
  Hank Bell

  Orăşean
• 
  Howard C. Hickman

  Southerner orating for votes