• 
  Paisley Blackburn

  The Witch
• 
  Leonard D. Sales

  John
• 
  Chris McDaniel

  TV Preist
• 
  Thomas D. Brown II

  Eddie
• 
  Elaine Marie

  The Black Lady
• 
  Christian McDaniel

  Chris
• 
  Austin David Fisher

  Craig
• 
  Che Jim

  Keith

• 
  Rhonda Nelson

  Craig's Mom
• 
  Ben Hividston

  The Jackson Driver
• 
  Ashley Wofford

  Jackson Girl Liz
• 
  Craig Whedon

  The Eavesdropping Neighbor
• 
  Jane Nichols

  Creepy Legends Team Member #2
• 
  Jordan Cooper

  Creepy Legends Team Member #4
• 
  Todd B. Miller

  Extra

• 
  Irfan Khan

  Adam
• 
  Ricky Iniesta

  Dennis
• 
  Haley Weston

  Kat
• 
  Amanjot Singh

  Store Clerk
• 
  Richard Nichols

  Creepy Legends Team Member #3
• 
  Kendra Howard

  Adam's wife
• 
  Adolfo Rodriguez

  Whiney Kevin
• 
  Emily Eckert

  Martha (voice)
• 
  Sara Jobes

  Michelle
• 
  Vonda McDaniel

  Creepy Legends Team Member #1