• 
  Tom Sizemore

  Knicks
• 
  Rick Ravanello

  Damon
• 
  Kevin Kate

  Middle-aged Priest
• 
  Kevin Shea

  Father Tito
• 
  Paul Drechsler-Martell

  Crooked Tooth
• 
  Greg Nutcher

  Father Leeds
• 
  Kerry McGann

  Mother Leeds
• 
  Anthony Del Negro

  Tommy

• 
  Steven A. Miller

  Jimmy
• 
  Adrienne LaValley

  Maya
• 
  Evalena Marie

  Zib
• 
  Paul Melluzzo

  Driver Bro
• 
  Jae Greene

  Glasses
• 
  Brett Lapeyrouse

  Bally Leader
• 
  Chris Dyer

  Freckles

• 
  Alex Kip

  Young Priest
• 
  Merphy Betancourt

  Curly Hair (as Murphy Betancourt)
• 
  Caitlin Zoz

  Midwife (as Caitlin McInerney)
• 
  Jacqui Denski

  Waitress
• 
  Jeff Orens

  Corley