• 
  John Kelly

  23 episodes, 2012-2014
• 
  M. William Phelps

   Himself - Host (20 episodes, 2012-2014)
• 
  Victoria Morgan

  Cassandra Lee Hailey
• 
  Shane Imbert

  Police Investigator
• 
  Jessica Drew

  Hooker
• 
  Yasmin Horner

  Jessica Cain
• 
  Kate Ryerson

  Cathleen Thomas
• 
  Samuel Campbell Wilson

  Israel Keyes

• 
  Darren K. Hawkins

  The Valley Killer
• 
  Megan Thomas

  Jane
• 
  Donna Brooks

  Mary
• 
  Melanie Thorpe

  Cathy
• 
  Melissa Armstrong

  Lynda
• 
  Ray Anger

  Self
• 
  Melissa Barthelemy

  Self

• 
  Cathy Broad

  Self
• 
  Heather Catallo

  Self
• 
  Emily Stratten

  Annamaria Phelps
• 
  Olivia Stiefel

  Nancy
• 
  Heather Ashley Chase

  Karen Osmuns
• 
  Leanne Mauro

  Barbara Breidor
• 
  Margaux Harris

  Stacey