• 
  Shiri Appleby

   Lucy (10 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Bryce Johnson

  Brendan
• 
  Toby Meuli

  Scott Cunningham
• 
  Alison Becker

   Kelcy (9 episodes)
• 
  Mircea Monroe

   Amanda (9 episodes)
• 
  Lindsey Kraft

   Tara Reed (5 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Taylor Kinney

  Dave
• 
  Leah Rachel

   Olivia Gold (6 episodes, 2012)

• 
  Candice Accola

  Chloe Cunningham
• 
  Travis Van Winkle

  Marc
• 
  Martin Starr

  Vincent
• 
  John Yuan

  Otto Dixon
• 
  Matt Yuan

  Frank Dixon
• 
  Brianna Brown

  Noelle
• 
  Zach McGowan

  Jagger

• 
  Fran Kranz

  Sorbet Guy
• 
  Brandon Tyles

  Bar Guy
• 
  Dey Young

  Mrs. Burke