• 
  Eric Titus

   Police Officer (2016)
• 
  Douglas Robbs

   Willie Bennett
• 
  Patrick McDaniel

   Charles Stuart
• 
  William Wallace

   Matthew Stuart
• 
  Moses Ntekereze

   Joey Bennet
• 
  Connor Moeller

   Kirk Buckner (2017)
• 
  Rachel Zapata

   Carol Stuart
• 
  Trevor Crane

   Don Pierce (1 episode)

• 
  Lance Coughlin

   NYPD officer (1 episode)
• 
  Daniel Patrick Smith

   Robert Chambers (1 episode)
• 
  Liam Higgins

   Kansas City Cop / ... (1 episode)
• 
  Shaun Kennedy

   Bartender (1 episode)
• 
  Steve Boghossian

   Steve Buckner (1 episode)
• 
  Matthew Wise

   NYPD Officer (1 episode)
• 
  Kobi Frumer

   Timothy Buckner (1 episode)

• 
  Patrick Gallagher

   Narrator (1 episode)
• 
  Robert House

   Detective Miller Thomas (1 episode)
• 
  Avery Mull

   Claudia Pikul (1 episode)
• 
  James Rose

   FBI Agent Bob Gast (1 episode)
• 
  Bill Hoffmann

   Himself (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Benjamin Oduro

   Cosmo Fallarino / ... (3 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Loydeen

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Rob Tunstall

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Bradley Bemboom

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Anna Andersen

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Nori J. Muster

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Henry Doktorski

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Gaura Rader

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Jacob Young

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Aaron Dalla Villa

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Becky Boggs

  Robyn Arnold
• 
  Elle Gabriel

  Cheerleader friend
• 
  Tom Westfall

  Self