• 
  Randall Bosley

  The Collector
• 
  Cameron Bowen

  Brian
• 
  Damien Puckler

  Simon
• 
  Jeromy Thorsen

  Ren
• 
  Braxton Davis

  Bill
• 
  Jacob Hobbs

  Kip
• 
  Rick Williamson

  Albert Fish (as Rick Williams)
• 
  Tonya Kay

  Star

• 
  Christy Keller

  Jan
• 
  Milly Sanders

  Daisy
• 
  Mara Hall

  Auntie May
• 
  Semi Anthony

  JB
• 
  Hawk Walts

  John Wayne Gacy
• 
  Charito Mertz

  Candi
• 
  Ire Wardlaw

  Nicole

• 
  Rick Williamson

  Albert Fish (as Rick Williams)