• 
  Carmen Argenziano

  Don Quixote
• 
  Buck Acosta

  Villager
• 
  Joseph Argenziano

  Holy Brotherhood Member
• 
  James Franco

  Pasamonte
• 
  Flash

  Rocinante
• 
  Chile

  Dapple
• 
  Lin Shaye

  The Grand Lady
• 
  Steve Bannos

  The Innkeeper

• 
  Jacquie Barnbrook

  Teresa Panza
• 
  Daniel Betances

  Front Guard
• 
  Gary Carlos Cervantes

  Armed Brother
• 
  Michael Delaney

  Man with Basin
• 
  Daren Flam

  Rear Guard
• 
  Luis Guzmán

  Farmer
• 
  Alison Lees-Taylor

  Younger Wench

• 
  Anthony Skordi

  Father Nicolas
• 
  Eduardo Yáñez

  Mounted Brother
• 
  Reinaldo Zavarce

  Miguel
• 
  Joseph Callari

  Villager #3
• 
  John Charles Meyer

  Enrique
• 
  Vic Stagliano

  Galley Slave
• 
  Vera Cherny

  Dulcinea
• 
  Tarek Tohme

  White Knight (voice)
• 
  Alberto Jorrin

  Villager #1
• 
  Nancy Atalla

  Woman on Bench
• 
  Jim Mitchell

  Villager
• 
  William Leon

  Teenage Boy
• 
  Lorena McGregor

  Antonia
• 
  Adam Chernick

  Sancho Panza's Son
• 
  Victoria Hannath

  Villager