• 
  Jackie Pirico

  4 episodes, 2018
• 
  Tim Gilbert

  Himself - Host
• 
  John Gallagher

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Dylan Gott

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Dave Alexander

  Self - Judge
• 
  Brandon Ash Mohammed

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Aisha Brown

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Laura Dennis

  Self - Contestant

• 
  Thompson Egbo-Egbo

  Self - Contestant
• 
  John Gallagher

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Todd Graham

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Ashley Gray

  Self - Judge
• 
  Jesse Guilmette

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Peter Hodgins

  Lorne Michaels
• 
  Judy Kaye

  Self - Judge

• 
  Matt Kowall

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Maggie Mahoney

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Anne T. Donahue

  Self - Contestant