• 
  Elise Schultz

  Phone Sex Misty
• 
  Mike Lamps

  Theater Usher
• 
  Heather Ruth

  Jenny #2
• 
  Cory Whitford

  Lost Dog Man
• 
  Christopher E. Engler

  Elliott
• 
  Travis Legge

  Jenny's Friends (6)
• 
  Melissa Revels

  Final Jenny
• 
  Ty Yaeger

  Broken Car Man

• 
  Tim Stotz

  Courtney
• 
  Jason Ssg

  Boragard's Son
• 
  Abbie Yaeger

  Broken Car Woman
• 
  Chelsea Foss Ralston

  Bad Cop
• 
  Jessica Opon

  Jenny #3
• 
  Jennifer Alten

  Shawna
• 
  Kelly Beaman

  Jenny's Friends (4)

• 
  Erik Pierson

  Matt
• 
  Sandra Johnson

  Elaine
• 
  Daniel Wagner

  Young Cupid
• 
  Molly Butz

  Jenny #34
• 
  Susie Wallin

  Ashley
• 
  Nicole Butkevich

  Party Hottie 1
• 
  Leah Rae Brown

  Dawn
• 
  Jennifer Loomis

  Bumper Car Woman
• 
  Favian Franco

  Jenny's Friends (3)
• 
  Peter Hackman

  Bryce
• 
  Melanie Templeton

  Jenny #1
• 
  Xavier Whitford

  Jenny #17
• 
  Megan Martin

  Partie Hottie 2
• 
  Kellithy Engler

  Harmony (as Kelly Engler)
• 
  Giovani Benitez

  Jenny's Friends (5)
• 
  Steven McDevitt

  Hercules
• 
  Natalie Penix

  Jenny #46
• 
  Greg Reilly

  Good Cop Hitch
• 
  Sara Honchar

  Bartender
• 
  Cori McDevitt

  Jenny #54
• 
  Taya Benitez

  Psyche
• 
  Anthony Day

  Bumper Car Man
• 
  Jenn Ramczyk

  Lost Dog Woman
• 
  Anna Toornman

  Michelle
• 
  Jinger Christal

  Lana
• 
  Frank Green

  Jenny's Friends (2)
• 
  David Lewis

  Jenny's Friends (1)
• 
  Michael Elgindy

  D.J.
• 
  Tim Toornman

  Drew
• 
  Victoria Johns

  Sara
• 
  Bryson Lay

  Worm