• 
  Kris Mohandie

  Self
• 
  Rob Morgan
• 
  Justin Morck

   James Marlow / ... (2 episodes, 2012-2013)
• 
  Kae Cohen

   Detective Coulton / ... (2 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Katherine Ramsland

  Self
• 
  Alena Acker

  June Cicero
• 
  Jonah Young

  Larry Bittaker
• 
  Richard Fallin

  Self - Former Detective, Montgomery County PD

• 
  Christina Springle

  Brenda White
• 
  Ed Tarney

  Self - Former Detective, Montgomery County PD
• 
  Adrian Havill

  Self - Author
• 
  Justin Gerhard

  James Ferris
• 
  Anne-Marie Agbodji

  Sandra
• 
  Mikaal Bates

  Voice of Killer
• 
  J.D. Brown

  Detective Fallin

• 
  Mark Carapezza

  Voice of the Killer
• 
  Risa Cohen

  Adrienne Cullen
• 
  Isaac Cruz

  Voice of the Killer
• 
  Shawn Curran

  Frank Hilley
• 
  Gregg McCrary

  Self
• 
  Barbara Kirwin

  Self
• 
  Kenric Green

  Nathaniel White
• 
  Lauren Ashleigh

  Laura Houghteling
• 
  Thomas R. Waters

  Jeff (The Neighbor)
• 
  Robert Sciglimpaglia

  Larry Dean
• 
  Steven Gaswirth

  Police Officer 1