• 
  Arielle Kebbel

  Belle
• 
  Dylan O'Brien

  Peter
• 
  Seth Morris

  Toby Harris
• 
  Allison Hord

  Beth
• 
  Anna Wenger

  Tiffany
• 
  Suzi Barrett

  Lizzie
• 
  Julie Brister

  Melinda
• 
  Heather Anne Campbell

  Janene

• 
  Sergio Cilli

  Friend #1
• 
  Rob Delaney

  Brad
• 
  Noureen DeWulf

  Sarah
• 
  Irfaan Fredericks

  Toby's Friend
• 
  Lyle Friederichs

  Kyle
• 
  Erinn Hayes

  Megan
• 
  Kevin Michael Hoffman

  Bartender

• 
  Angela Kinsey

  April
• 
  Angela Trimbur

  Morgan
• 
  June Diane Raphael

  Toby's Date