• 
  Eileen Dietz

  Mae Tillerman
• 
  Danny Hansen

  Braeden James
• 
  Brett Wagner

  Jacob Wright
• 
  Mike Sweet

  Sheriff Noah Hutton
• 
  William "Will" Daubert

  John Hutton
• 
  Jennifer Nangle

  Katie Burkhart
• 
  Nick Theurer

  Mason James
• 
  Christopher Huff

  Detective Colton Reid

• 
  Noel Jason Scott

  Frank DeFeo
• 
  Carissa White

  Kara Evans
• 
  Tom Patrick Propofsky

  Horace Fenwick
• 
  Jackie Gerhardy

  Alexandria DeFeo
• 
  Anthony Bratts

  Deputy Owen Greenwell
• 
  Madison Yergensen

  Zoe Biermann
• 
  Sarah Kay Clevinger

  Claire Evans

• 
  John J. Lund

  The Guardian
• 
  Trevor Sean

  Scott Fenwick
• 
  Cadence Clevinger

  Riley Evans