• 
  Stephanie Marie

  Maria (segment "Housewarming")
• 
  George Stover

  Festering Frank (segment "Frames of Fear")
• 
  Richard Mogg

  Groundskeeper (segment "Format of the Dead")
• 
  Dale Wilson

  Mr. Birch (segment "Housewarming")
• 
  Shawn C. Phillips

  Tommy Peterson (segment "Frames of Fear")
• 
  Amy Woo

  Ginger (segment "Morty and Chester's Grim Return")
• 
  Josh Schafer

  Dave (segment "Video Decay")
• 
  Rosanna Nelson

  Svetlana (segment "Wrestlemassacre")

• 
  Maggie Hill

  Tracy (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Richie Acevedo

  Biff (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Lindsay Lockhart

  Roxanne (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Jesse L. Green

  Det. Richards (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Rick Jermain

  Det. Stevens (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Martin W. Payne

  Tim (segment "Night Demon")
• 
  Hayden Hall

  Demon (segment "Video Decay")

• 
  Erica Jones

  Pamela (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Kirk Munaweera

  Tony (segment "Format of the Dead")
• 
  David S. Hart

  Morty (segment "Morty and Chester's Grim Return")
• 
  Laura Sophia Becker

  Kate (segment "Night Demon")
• 
  Jaysen Cochran

  Randy (segment "Wrestlemassacre")
• 
  Ryan Hill

  Shades (segment "Video Decay")
• 
  Maia Jade

  Girl in line (segment "Video Decay")
• 
  Steve Ferguson

  Chester (segment "Format of the Dead")
• 
  Doug Ferguson

  Eddie (segment "Format of the Dead")
• 
  Juurgen Van Abba

  Uncle Les (segment "Housewarming")
• 
  Rick Hammel

  Roger (segment "Housewarming")
• 
  Sheena Irwin

  Candy (segment "Morty and Chester's Grim Return")