• 
  Cecil Kellaway

  William
• 
  Joan Fontaine

  Dona St. Columb
• 
  Leslie Denison

  John Nankervis
• 
  Charles Irwin

  Zachariah Smith, jailer
• 
  Doris Lloyd

  Rol neidentificat
• 
  Charles Coleman

  Thomas (footman)
• 
  Henry A. Escalante

  Pirate Crewman
• 
  Phyllis Barry

  Woman in Gaming House

• 
  George Kirby

  Dr. Williams
• 
  Mary Field

  Prue
• 
  Nigel Bruce

  Lord Godolphin
• 
  Frank Hagney

  Cornishman
• 
  David Clyde

  Martin (coachman)
• 
  Al Ferguson

  Jail Guard
• 
  Ralph Forbes

  Harry St. Columb

• 
  Leyland Hodgson

  Invitat
• 
  David Cavendish

  Invitat
• 
  Basil Rathbone

  Lord Rockingham
• 
  Ronald R. Rondell

  Pirate Crewman
• 
  Arturo de Córdova

  Jean Benoit Aubrey