• 
  Jake Busey

  Charlie Sullivan
• 
  Tony Head

  Deputy Sheriff
• 
  Maria Olsen

  The Witch
• 
  Kelli Berglund

  Sally Sullivan
• 
  Danielle Muehlen

  Witch
• 
  Olivia Larsen

  Zoe
• 
  Mary Anisi

  Sister Brigit
• 
  Kylie Kiss

  Little Zoe

• 
  Shiloh Verrico

  Martha
• 
  Faye Giordano

  Little Sally
• 
  Karen Xerri

  Witch
• 
  KhalilJai

  Bike Kid #1
• 
  Vegas

  Bike Kid #2
• 
  Will White

  Bike Kid #3
• 
  Joah Carmody

  Reed

• 
  Joe D'Onofrio

  Deputy Simmons
• 
  Jason James Richter

  Deputy T
• 
  Royce Johnson

  Sheriff D.
• 
  Nikki Blonsky

  Mrs. E
• 
  Zebedee Row

  Billy
• 
  Jacqi Vene

  Sidekick / Laura
• 
  Grace Narducci

  Sidekick
• 
  Shifra Zuckerman

  Sidekick
• 
  Riley Victoria

  Jade