• 
  Tara Reid

  Mitzy Hollinger
• 
  Kevin Sorbo

  Chase Riley
• 
  Zahn McClarnon

  Rumored
• 
  Gerald Auger

  (rumored)
• 
  Wes Trudell

  Thorn Rivers
• 
  Kyle Agnew

  Messenger Soldier
• 
  Paul Thomas Arnold

  (rumored)
• 
  Rick Cordeiro

  (rumored)

• 
  Jazmyn Slaughter

  Young Nina Bolton
• 
  Saginaw Grant

  James Ghostkiller (rumored)
• 
  Tantoo Cardinal

  Aunt Rosie Stillwind (rumored)
• 
  Tobin Bell

  Special Agent Lee Tarkington / 1862 Herbert Tarkington
• 
  Tom Jackson

  Sheriff Mason Crow-Walker
• 
  Bob Gunton

  Father Wilson O'Rourke
• 
  Geraldine Keams

  Aunt Rosie Still-Wind

• 
  Michael Spears

  Shakopee
• 
  Eddie Spears

  Chaske Ghostkiller