• 
  Richard Blais

   Himself - Host
• 
  Michelle Crisostomo Lee

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Jeff Dunham

   Himself - Host (4 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Sandra Lee

   Herself - Judge (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Carla Hall

   Herself - Judge (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Damiano Carrara

   Himself - Judge (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  John Henson

  3 episodes, 2017
• 
  Zac Young

  3 episodes, 2017

• 
  Lorraine Pascale

  3 episodes, 2017
• 
  Andrew Fuller

  Self
• 
  Michelle Antonishek

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Damien Bagley

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Tamara Brown

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Brad Rudd

  Self - Contestant
• 
  John Schopp

  Self - Contestant

• 
  Amy Strickland

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Veronica von Borstel

  Self - Contestant
• 
  Stephanie Boswell

  Self - Judge
• 
  Aaron Clouse

  Self - Executive Pastry Chef, Columbus. OH
• 
  Renee Loranger

  Self - Executive Pastry Chef, Waveland, MS
• 
  Sinai Vespie

  Self - Executive Pastry Chef, Mishawaka, IN
• 
  Jonathan Elias

  Self 2017
• 
  Michael Gaddy

  Self - Pastry Chef, Dade City, FL
• 
  Brian Bosch

  Self - Home Baker, Santa Ana, CA
• 
  Holly Braddock

  Self - Executive Pastry Chef, Myrtle Beach, SC