• 
  Andrea Adams

  Tara Sheets (segment "The Tape")
• 
  Mike Malloy

  Ted (segment "Thicker Than Water")
• 
  Melanie Dean

  Girl 1 (segment "A Very Bad Situation")
• 
  Mike Burnell

  Gary (segment "The Tape")
• 
  Alexis Codding

  Madison (segment "The Scout")
• 
  Kayla Barbour

  Jogger / Bloody Victim (segment "Switchblade Insane")
• 
  Alaine Huntington

  Emily (segment "Thicker than Water")
• 
  Olivia Blake

  Injured Girl (segment "A Very Bad Situation")

• 
  Baker Chase Powell

  Brett (wraparound segment "No Budget Films Presents...")
• 
  Ashley Andel

  Screaming Woman (segment "Thicker than Water")
• 
  Vanessa Nocera

  Lauren (segment "Thicker than Water")
• 
  Bobbi Beach

  Phoebe (segment "The Tape")
• 
  Aiden Crain

  Child on Beach 1 (segment "Thicker than Water")
• 
  Ava Cronin

  Ms. Jezebel (segment "Switchblade Insane")
• 
  Jay Burris

  Tom (segment "Gang Them Style")

• 
  Kristin Avery

  Female Reporter (segment "A Very Bad Situation")