• 
  Matt Walsh

  Dave
• 
  James Adomian

  Donovan
• 
  Meredith Hagner

  Katelyn
• 
  Michael Cera

  Bennie
• 
  Julia Stiles
• 
  Amy Carlson

  Christina Casserta
• 
  Erinn Hayes

  Maddy
• 
  David Koechner

  Rich

• 
  Matty Blake

  Officer Blauser
• 
  Jake Cherry

  Cory
• 
  Wyatt Cenac

  Babatunde
• 
  Vivian Kalinov

  Stenographer
• 
  Jessie Ennis

  Juli
• 
  Kurt Braunohler

  Marshal
• 
  Rosemary Howard

  Mrs. Torelli

• 
  Janet Krupin

  Megyn
• 
  Danny Flaherty

  (as Daniel Flaherty)
• 
  Jason Edward Cook

  Frail Hipster Kid
• 
  Nikki Holister

  Julie's Friend
• 
  Candida Guevara

  Bridget
• 
  Keith Mueller

  Mr. Hapsburg
• 
  Lianna Nielsen

  Carissa Ferrara
• 
  Jacob Devik

  News Crew
• 
  Sunny Edelman

  Member of the Press
• 
  Jason Ritter

  Julian
• 
  Amy Sedaris

  Crystal
• 
  Derek Waters

  Larson