• 
  Joe Boyd

  Ezekiel Yoder
• 
  Matthew Donnelly

  Bob 'Dirty' Rivers
• 
  Mike Betette

  Dean Livy
• 
  Aidan Boyd

  Josiah Yoder
• 
  Amanda Ohly

  Miriam Yoder
• 
  Annie Murphy

  Scooter Girl Trainee #3
• 
  Anthony W. Carter

  Poker Dealer
• 
  Ashley E. Boehm

  Waitress

• 
  Bekka Prewitt

  Rebecca Masterson
• 
  Bobby Rodgers

  Mayor Stetson
• 
  Cameron Comstock

  Poker Dealer
• 
  Chip Redden

  Poker Dealer
• 
  Chris Heaton

  Rock Russell
• 
  Christopher Day

  William Argo
• 
  Christopher Smyth

  Jedediah

• 
  Daniel Smyth

  Congregant
• 
  Dean McKenzie

  Dusty
• 
  Debbie Boyd

  Scooter Girl Trainee #2
• 
  Devra Rochelle

  Losing Poker Player
• 
  Eddie Annal

  Mr. Ripley
• 
  Eli Boyd

  Luke Yoder
• 
  Elliot Docherty

  Mark Yoder
• 
  Gavin Docherty

  Matthew Yoder
• 
  Gregg Swadener

  Congregant
• 
  Holly Walker

  Jill Fields
• 
  Isaac Stambaugh

  Deputy Hutchinson
• 
  Jen Johnson

  Keri Kerrington
• 
  Jocelyn Sluka

  Older Lady Fighter #1
• 
  John Bromels

  Fire Guy
• 
  Jon Eric Hoffman

  Poker Dealer
• 
  Joseph E. Elam

  Main Poker Dealer
• 
  Karen Krueger

  Doris Livy
• 
  Kathryn Remesch-Sarnecki

  Older Lady Fighter #3
• 
  Korey T. Kiepert

  Wild Willy Wilder
• 
  Leah Ransohoff

  Geeky Friend #1
• 
  Luke Pater

  Biker Guy
• 
  Mary Kay Swadener

  Congregant
• 
  Mat Thornburg

  Scotty Argo
• 
  Megan Soule

  Carol Marshall
• 
  Melissa Scalia

  Scooter Girl Trainee #1
• 
  Missy Whitis

  Organist
• 
  Nick Ghizas

  Josh Rivers
• 
  Paula Zo

  Older Lady Fighter #2
• 
  Peggy Murphy

  Mrs. Murphy
• 
  Quinn Cifani

  Mary Yoder
• 
  Rammi Esreb

  Poker Dealer
• 
  Randy Cash

  Scooter Jones
• 
  Russ Beckner

  Rusty
• 
  Scott Docherty

  Father Clive Hayden
• 
  Sean Michael Murphy

  Rev. Thomas Masterson