• 
  Josh Brandon

  Gary Poole
• 
  Robert Bothun

  Himself - Timothy's Brother
• 
  Skip Arms

  Himself - Homicide Detective
• 
  David Schifter

  Detective J.D. Walker
• 
  Bryan Bergman

  Brian Howlett
• 
  Monique A. Miller

  Media Reporter #2
• 
  Aaron Tyler

  Black Dante
• 
  Nicholas Cordts

  Dave Garrett

• 
  Zach Douglas

  Duane Castle
• 
  Chester Goad

  Neighbor
• 
  Jp Lambert

  Dante Roane (White Dante)
• 
  Jamil Khan

  Joe Medina
• 
  Michael Gladden

  Detective Dave Moore
• 
  Chris Steele

  Marvin Knapp
• 
  Nicholas Ramsay

  Nathaniel Simmons

• 
  Carson Zone

  Scott Eacker
• 
  Tim Bothun

  Himself (archive footage)
• 
  Josh Casaubon

  Narrator
• 
  Sandra Mann

  Herself - Local News Reporter
• 
  Emily Lane

  Laurie Wheeler
• 
  Joe Kenda

  Himself - Host / Lt. Homicide Detective
• 
  Chris Caulpetzer

  Police Officer
• 
  Carl Marino

  Lt. Joe Kenda
• 
  Sedona Feretto

  Tracy Lee