• 
  Elohim Peña

  Kerry Reynosa (as Elohim Pena)
• 
  Ben Shaul

  Adriano (segment "Until Forever")
• 
  Reinhold Von Bolt

  Gabriel (segment "Until Forever)
• 
  Jillian Lebling

  Elayna (segment "Until Forever")
• 
  Jay Rattle

  Obed (segment "Until Forever)
• 
  Dan Davies

  Detective Scott Redmayne (segment "Answers")
• 
  H. Adoni Esho

  Detective Ashur Nassar (Segment "Answers")
• 
  Peter Knox

  Carl Crimwood (Segment "Answers")

• 
  Nakada Wilson

  Deena Swann (Segment "Answers")
• 
  Eshan Khalani

  Daniel Parker (segment "Answers")
• 
  Mel (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")
• 
  Lonny (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")
• 
  Boy in the Devil Mask (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")
• 
  Caroline (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")
• 
  Principal Dennings (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")

• 
  Ivan (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")
• 
  Steven Alonte

  Charles / Psychopomp
• 
  Katelin Stack

  Rosemary
• 
  Danny Villanueva Jr.

  Julian Torres
• 
  Kulani Kai

  Evelyn Reynosa
• 
  Beth Johnson

  Dolores Valentine
• 
  David James Slama

  Police Officer