• 
  Mary Mouser

  Michelle
• 
  Adrienne Barbeau

  Rosemary
• 
  Lesley-Anne Down

  Sister Clare
• 
  John Savage

  Joseph
• 
  Brandon Beemer

  Father Dumal
• 
  Tobin Bell

  Monsignor Canell
• 
  Alexandra Davies

  Emily
• 
  Zen Gesner

  Stephen's Father

• 
  Carlene Moore

  Coach Carol
• 
  Elimu Nelson

  Randy O'Connor
• 
  Randy Shelly

  Stephen Tade
• 
  Alisha Boe

  Alexa O'Connor
• 
  Shane Schoeppner

  Hooded Priest
• 
  James D Thomas

  Student
• 
  Alexandria Davies

  Emily

• 
  Bronson Bard

  Ben
• 
  Dewey Hays

  Bully
• 
  Renee Dobre

  Cheerleader
• 
  Victoria Rose Mueller

  Young Michelle (as Victoria Mueller)
• 
  John Lobato

  Hooded Priest (uncredited)
• 
  Drake Seastrand

  Young Stephen
• 
  Shane Schoeppner

  Hooded Priest