• 
  Abbi Jacobson
• 
  Betsy Aidem

  Cindy (segment "Helberger in Paradise") (rumored)
• 
  Frederic Heringes

  Executive Chef (segment, "Cake")
• 
  Jocelin Donahue

  May (segment "Cake") (rumored)
• 
  Michael Borne

  Guy Andersen (segment "High and Dry") (rumored)
• 
  Jennifer Kim

  Su (segment "High and Dry") (rumored)
• 
  Rob Michael Hugel

  Arthur (segment "High and Dry") (rumored)
• 
  Kelly Hudson

  Eyeglass Salesperson 2 (segment "High and Dry")

• 
  Shannon Coffey

  Shannon (segment "Cake")
• 
  Steven Hall

  Ophthalmologist (segment "High and Dry") (rumored)
• 
  George Kareman

  Rosalie's Boyfriend (segment "Helberger In Paradise")
• 
  Ilana Glazer

  Animal Shelter Worker (segment "High and Dry") (rumored)
• 
  Dan Klein

  Eyeglass Salesperson 1 (segment, "High and Dry")
• 
  Glenn Alba

  Chef
• 
  Sonny Hoang

  Pregnant Woman (segment "Helberger In Paradise")