• 
  Tyler Gallant

  Johnny
• 
  Arch Hall Jr.

  Pa Wicker
• 
  Lynn Lowry

  Grandma O'Connor
• 
  Robert Allen Mukes

  The Butcher
• 
  Felissa Rose

  Angelina
• 
  Jim Van Bebber

  Rick
• 
  Tino Zamora

  Ace The Pizza Guy
• 
  Dale Miller

  Scab

• 
  John Wells

  Vincent
• 
  Timothy Patrick Quill

  Pop (segment "Homewrecked")
• 
  Joe Mannetti

  Don O'Connor (segment "Night of the Seamonkey")
• 
  Stacie Stocker

  Carrol O'Connor (segment "Night of the Seamonkey")
• 
  Sebrina Siegel

  Nora (segment "Homewrecked")
• 
  Michael S. Rodriguez

  (segment "Homewrecked")
• 
  Sean Laguna

  Toby O'Connor (segment "Night of the Seamonkey")

• 
  Meghan Chadeayne

  Marcy (segment "Homewrecked")
• 
  J.J. Beasley

  Kurt (segment "Homewrecked")
• 
  Alydah Raguindin

  Village Girl (segment "Homewrecked")
• 
  Caitlin Herst

  Audrey O'Connor (segment "Night of the Seamonkey")
• 
  Richard 'R.J.' Markham

  Clay O'Connor (segment "Night of the Seamonkey")