• 
  Arthur Steven Lange, Jr.

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Jimmy Brogan

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Bobby Kelly

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Mark Christopher Lawrence

   Himself - Host
• 
  Bonnie McFarlane

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Mel Novak

   Minister
• 
  Colin Quinn

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Rich Vos

   Celebrity Judge

• 
  Jim Norton

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Michael Joiner

   Mentor-Comedian (2017-)
• 
  David Nieker

   Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Lou Pizarro

   Celebrity Judge
• 
  Dana Dae

   Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Larry L Andrews

   Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Scott Wood

   Co Host

• 
  Larry Lowe

   Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Andy Peters

   Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Jillian Chiappone

   Celebrity Judge (as Jillian Chiaponnes)
• 
  Ed Greer

   Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Jodi Miller

  Mentor-Comedians
• 
  Jim Ruel

  Mentor-Comedians