• 
  Clarence Gilyard Jr.

  Ben Foreman
• 
  Michael Tylo

  Art Professor
• 
  Michael Vara

  Sam Stone
• 
  Adam Kilbourn

  Marshal Henderson
• 
  Annie Thalrose

  Lydia Pate
• 
  Brian Robak

  Man in Lot
• 
  Brian Trajano

  Editor
• 
  Briana Kennedy-Coker

  Waitress

• 
  Charles Cantrell

  Carl Withers
• 
  Chaz Greco

  Little Davey McClendon
• 
  Christopher Boeres Hipp

  Fred Harper
• 
  Danette Tull

  Office Assistant
• 
  Daniel Jaidar

  Detective
• 
  Danny Countess

  Marshal Parker
• 
  Darion Ramos

  Allyson

• 
  David Schmoeller

  Wakefield
• 
  Deana Deatherage

  Caller
• 
  Dee Drenta

  Maria Harper
• 
  Diana Eden

  Judge Clemens
• 
  Dustin Knouse

  Deputy Pete
• 
  Ellen Lawson

  Ida Withers
• 
  Evalyn Wells

  Little Girl
• 
  Jackson Larson

  Young Carl Withers
• 
  Jakob Sauter

  Simpson Clark
• 
  James Greco

  Young James Landers
• 
  Jason Neistadt

  G. Gordon Williams
• 
  Jason Wurst

  Pizza Guy
• 
  Jeffrey Koep

  Governor Templeton
• 
  Jeremy Cloe

  Voice of Mr. Spencer
• 
  Judyann Price

  Mona Landers
• 
  Kaleta Kuhlemeier

  Virginia
• 
  Kelly Schenk

  Make-up Artist
• 
  Kynan Dias

  Luke Abbott
• 
  Leah LoSchiavo

  Librarian
• 
  Luke Jones

  Nelson
• 
  Matthew Vorce

  Jt
• 
  May May Luong

  Little Girl's Mother
• 
  Megli Micek

  Beth
• 
  Michael Brown

  Deputy Brown
• 
  Michaelangelo Miller

  Assistant's Voice
• 
  Mike Wurst

  Detective
• 
  Nadia Stanko

  Stripper
• 
  Nathan Uhlig

  Joe Chalmers
• 
  Patrick Sean Clark

  Dr. Hartford
• 
  Phil Valentine

  G. McClendon
• 
  Roselynn Savage

  Darla
• 
  Ryan LeBoeuf

  James Landers
• 
  Sean McGlynn

  Ray Jordan
• 
  Shana Dahan

  Amanda McClendon
• 
  Spencer Larson

  Guy on the Street